The Land: No need for GM wheat

Opinion published in The Land, Thursday, July 28, 2011, p24.

AS AN agricultural scientist (ex-CSIRO) and consumer, I am deeply concerned about the lack of critical questioning arising from the genetically modified (GM) GM wheat debate.

Several correspondents in The Land say GM wheat will give better crops and healthier products, and that GMs have not caused health issues. But you don’t know what you don’t monitor and measure.

Worldwide there are no multiple-generation animal feeding studies and there is no surveillance of impacts on human health.

Unauthorised studies show animal health and fertility problems after the first generation.

We don’t need GM wheat as problems can be solved by working on their causes.

For human health switch to wholemeal bread and eat less over-processed food.

GM wheat will allow us to keep eating a less unhealthy white bread.

Many innovative farmers have demonstrated improved quantity and quality of produce by increasing soil fertility through activating soil biology and improving soil carbon.

This is in association with cutting the use of synthetic fertilisers and chemicals.

During the long drought biological farmers had higher yields than neighbours, so there’s no need for drought-tolerant GM wheat.

Examples of success in biological farming are regularly reported in The Land. Science institutions and GRDC still tend to ignore it and continue to waste valuable research and development funds on GM research.

Recent UN reports about feeding the world support biological farming and reject GM.

DR MAARTEN STAPPER,

BioLogic AgFood,

Holder, ACT.

 

The Land: Not so independent?

Opinion published in The Land, Thursday, August 11, 2011, p18.

HOW independent are these leading Australian grains industry members when they dismiss suggestions genetically modified (GM) wheat has been roundly rejected in Australia and overseas? (“Industry rejects Greenpeace claims”, The Land, July 28, p16).

Which survey results show their 80 to 90 per cent of graingrowers supporting GM wheat research?

They dismiss rejection overseas with the statement from the National Association of Wheat Growers (NAWG) that US growers are “excited about using the potential benefits”.

The top three sponsors of NAWG are the world-leading biotechnology companies.

Meanwhile, 83pc of Canadian farmers reject GM wheat.

A 2009 peer-reviewed journal reported that: “GM wheat was abandoned in 2004, but industry groups and their partners are now seeking its reintroduction. However, the great majority of Canadian farmers, many themselves growing GM canola, felt that risks associated with GM wheat far outweighed any benefits.”

Overall, farmers ranked the risks of market loss, corporate control of the food supply, agronomic impact and contamination of non-GM crops much higher than any anticipated production benefits.

Awareness is growing of long-term impacts of GM on environment and human health with studies in North and South America showing negative outcomes after 15 years of GM crops.

Reasons for our industry groups to support GM wheat are the long-standing promises of “grain yield, drought and heat tolerance, nitrogen use efficiency, frost tolerance and fungal disease resistance”.

For many of our innovative farmers those outcomes are already being achieved with current genes on healthy soils.

Crops can be managed to increase soil fertility by activating soil biology and improving soil carbon while reducing use of synthetic fertilisers and chemicals.

DR MAARTEN STAPPER,

BioLogic AgFood,

Holder, ACT.

 

Organic Expo International

An interview with Maarten at Organic Expo International on 6 August:

[Watch the 5 Part Presentation here]

GM in our daily bread? Part 1

A GM discussion by Dr Maarten Stapper in 5 parts recorded by Francois of ScandinavianMedia in the Speakers’ Corner of the Organic Expo & Green Show International at Sydney on 6 August…

GM in our daily bread? Part 2

A GM discussion by Dr Maarten Stapper in 5 parts recorded by Francois of ScandinavianMedia in the Speakers’ Corner of the Organic Expo & Green Show International at Sydney on 6 August…

GM in our daily bread? Part 3

A GM discussion by Dr Maarten Stapper in 5 parts recorded by Francois of ScandinavianMedia in the Speakers’ Corner of the Organic Expo & Green Show International at Sydney on 6 August…

 

GM in our daily bread? Part 4

A GM discussion by Dr Maarten Stapper in 5 parts recorded by Francois of ScandinavianMedia in the Speakers’ Corner of the Organic Expo & Green Show International at Sydney on 6 August…

GM in our daily bread? Part 5

A GM discussion by Dr Maarten Stapper in 5 parts recorded by Francois of ScandinavianMedia in the Speakers’ Corner of the Organic Expo & Green Show International at Sydney on 6 August…

VIDEO: Agricultural Science and Technology is Stuck in a Rut

Presented at the 10th International Permaculture Conference in Jordan and recorded by Craig Mackintosh who gives the following introduction.

“I’ve been a fan of Maarten Stapper’s work for a while now. In fact, further below you’ll find an article I wrote, way back in 2007, about his experiences at the hands of his former employer — Australia’s publicly funded CSIRO agricultural research body. I’d recommend you read the article before watching Maarten’s IPC10 Convergence presentation, as it’ll give you a good backgrounder on his valuable work and his commendable ethics. I say ethics because instead of compromising his principles so as to retain favour with those putting bread on his table, he stood his ground… and got sacked instead.

Continue reading

Genetically modified food: the wrong path for Australia?

Greenpeace’s radical action in destroying genetically modified wheat crops being trialled by the CSIRO in Canberra has catapulted the issue of GM foods on to the Australian food table.

The government has plans to introduce GM wheat by 2015 but a former CSIRO scientist says they’ve got it all wrong. Features: Dr Maarten Stapper, farming systems agronomist and former CSIRO employee; Dr Jeremy Burdon, Chief of the Division of Plant Industry, CSIRO; Cam McKellar, biological crop farmer, Spring Ridge, north west New South Wales; Laura Kelly, Head of Food and Farming Campaign, Greenpeace.

http://www.thewire.org.au/daydetail.aspx?SearchDay=2011-07-15

Download the mp3